I wrote about rent controls here a few months ago. I closed that post with a quote from economist Assar Lindbeck. “Next to bombing, rent control seems in many cases to be the most efficient technique so far known for destroying cities.”
Since writing that post, New York has enacted more rent controls and the destroying effects of rent controls are now beginning to appear.
From The Wall Street Journal:
Barely a month has gone since New York passed its new rent-control law, and the predictable problems are fast emerging. Blackstone Group , which owns the Manhattan developments of Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village, is putting renovations on hold, reports Crain’s New York Business.
“In light of the recent legislation, we are in the process of evaluating capital investments at Stuy Town,” a Blackstone spokeswoman said. Maintenance, such as fixing leaks, must legally continue. But Crain’s, citing an unnamed source, says “renovations to vacant units would stop, as would potentially larger construction projects.”
Together the two properties cover roughly 24 city blocks. They include more than 11,000 apartments, some of which fall under the state’s rent regulations. Because the complex was originally built in the 1940s, sprucing up is necessary.
The old rules at least gave landlords some leeway to recoup costs. When an apartment became vacant, rent could rise 20%. If rent passed $2,774, the regulation ended, and the market rate could be applied. The new law axed those provisions, lowering the incentive to invest and update properties.
Stuy Town and Blackstone are making the news because they’re enormous, but the same logic applies to every building owner. Economists are more or less unanimous in calling rent control destructive. The only short-term winners are people who’ve already locked in.
The Stuy Town tenants association favored the new rent law. No wonder: Its president told another newspaper in 2016 that she moved in 35 years ago and was still paying less than $1,400 for a one-bedroom. You might call that the low price of stagnation, but wait until neighboring apartments deteriorate around her.
In Oregon, which implemented statewide rent controls recently, Karen Sale notes in a comment at this post that the law “dramatically affects Oregon landlords. Many are putting their long term rentals on the market for sale.”
H/T to economicpolicyjournal.com
