I delved into real estate investing because I thought it would save me from the misery of living paycheck-to-paycheck. I’m 2 months into my rehab and I’ve found that not much has changed yet. I’m rehabbing paycheck-to-paycheck. When I’m shopping for tools and supplies, it’s no surprise that I reach for cheap. I look for deals and I do the work myself.
Not everyone shares my sentiments concerning frugality. I bought a Husky crescent wrench and was advised to buy better tools. My plumber strongly recommended that I install a new, double-basin sink. My partner and I disagreed when I insisted on using a combination of old and new shoe molding. This isn’t how I imagined my investor persona!
I justify my frugality by telling myself that I can replace it all during my next vacancy. I need to get my second unit cash-flowing so that I can better fund repairs. I ask myself if my tenants will know the difference. This is when I turned to Kevin. I emailed him, “when is cheap NOT worth it?” This is his response:
- When it involves gas.
- When it involves electric.
- When it wastes your time. You have to understand the value of your time. You may need to pay a plumber for a service call, but they will get it done right and quick. You may be able to do it, but it will take you four times as long to do it. You will have to make three trips to Home Depot to finish it.
- Appliances! Just buy a new “used” one rather than trying to replace parts. Unless it is incredibly simple to fix, it is just not worth it. The part will cost almost as much as the replacement appliance. You will most likely order or receive the wrong part. Beware, many parts look the same but have slight differences. Trust me on this.
- Is it really cheaper for you to do it? Don’t try to save money if it is costing you potential rent. Take a rehab for example: You do it all yourself and it takes two months. You could have had it rented at a rate of $625 per month. A contractor could have had the job done in 2 weeks for $1500. Did you really save any money?
I appreciate Kevin’s emphasis on avoiding repairs with safety implications: gas and electricity. I was considering teaching myself how to repair appliances, but I think I’ve axed the idea. For the time being though, it makes financial sense for me to most of these repairs myself. Sometimes cheap is worth it, and sometimes it’s not.
Save
- We used the cheapest vinyl tile at Home Depot and the kitchen floor looks great. You don’t even notice the mismatched shoe molding.
- We shopped for used cabinets. We bought unfinished cabinets and painted them. The cabinets look great.
Spend
- We bought the cheapest paint brushes we could find, and it was a horrible decision. The hairs fall out and get stuck in the paint. Don’t do it!
- We paid full price for a window air conditioning unit. I never will again. I later came across two used ac units, which were three times better for a third of the price.
While I advocate for frugality, please don’t cut corners by sacrificing quality installation. Tenants and buyers will notice. I firmly believe going cheap should be our current strategy. We rehabbed the entire kitchen of unit 1 for less than $1,000. It looks so much better than before. I look forward to seeing it look even better than now.
Do you have any advice? When is cheap worth it and when is it not?